Signs of Mental Health: Realistic and Reliable Self-Esteem
Healthy self-esteem is not about feeling good about yourself all the time. It is about having a stable, balanced, and grounded sense of who you are. One that can hold both your strengths and your limitations without collapsing or becoming inflated.
The Development of Self-Esteem
Self-esteem develops gradually over time, shaped largely through early relational experiences.
The Australian psychotherapist Russell Meares describes the importance of a warm, intimate feeling tone in early development. When a child experiences consistent emotional attunement of feeling seen, valued, and responded to, this becomes the foundation for a stable sense of self-worth.
When this kind of emotional warmth is absent, as in cases of neglect or chronic misattunement, self-esteem can become fragile or underdeveloped. Rather than feeling inherently worthwhile, a person may come to depend heavily on external validation or struggle with a persistent sense of inadequacy.
When Self-Esteem Becomes Unbalanced
Difficulties with self-esteem can emerge in different ways.
An overinflated sense of self can lead to patterns often associated with grandiosity, where a person may struggle to accurately assess their own limitations. On the other end, self-esteem can collapse, leading to feelings of worthlessness, shame, or chronic self-doubt.
Most people who seek therapy tend to struggle more with the latter. A common pattern is holding oneself to unrealistic internal standards while extending understanding and compassion to others.
The psychoanalyst Karen Horney described this dynamic as the “tyranny of the shoulds.” These “shoulds” take the form of rigid, perfectionistic demands about who you are supposed to be or what you are supposed to achieve.
Because these standards are often unattainable, they create a cycle of striving and falling short. The ideal being pursued is not grounded in reality, but in an internalised image shaped by early environments where one never quite felt “good enough.”
Realistic Self-Esteem
To have realistic self-esteem is to hold yourself to standards that are grounded and achievable.
This does not mean lowering expectations to the point of disengagement. Rather, it means recognising your human limits and acknowledging that you will make mistakes, fall short at times, and still remain fundamentally worthwhile.
Realistic self-esteem allows for self-reflection without harsh self-judgement. It creates space for growth without the constant pressure of perfection.
Reliable Self-Esteem
Alongside being realistic, healthy self-esteem is also reliable.
A reliable sense of self-worth is not easily shaken by criticism, nor is it overly inflated by praise. It provides a kind of internal stability that allows you to take in feedback without being overwhelmed by it.
When self-esteem is unreliable, even small criticisms can feel devastating, while positive feedback may be either dismissed or clung to as the sole source of worth.
When it is reliable, both positive and negative feedback can be integrated more evenly.
A Balanced Sense of Self
In people with healthy self-esteem, there is a grounded and nuanced self-image.
They are able to recognise their strengths and capacities, while also acknowledging their limitations and vulnerabilities. These aspects are not split apart, but held together within a coherent sense of self.
This balance has important relational effects. It allows a person to express needs, take responsibility, apologise and repair when necessary, and speak honestly about their experience.
Perhaps most importantly, it supports the ability to be seen by others without excessive fear or defensiveness.
Developing realistic and reliable self-esteem is not about becoming endlessly confident or self-assured.
It is about building a steadier internal foundation can hold complexity, tolerate imperfection, and remain intact across different situations and relationships.
In therapy, this often involves gently challenging unrealistic standards, understanding where they came from, and developing a more compassionate and grounded relationship with oneself.
Moving Forward
Self-esteem, when balanced, becomes a quiet but essential support for mental health.
It allows you to move through the world with a sense of stability—able to take risks, engage with others, and grow, without being constantly derailed by self-doubt or inflated by illusion.
In the next post, we will explore another sign of mental health: resilience and flexibility.
Do you need mental health support in Warrnambool?
Start feeling like yourself again. Contact Us Today!
Book an Appointment
Do you need mental health support in Warrnambool?
Start feeling like yourself again. Contact Us Today!
Book an AppointmentAbout the author
